• National Journal.com
  • Sign In

  • My Account | Free Trial

    Submit site feedback

nationaljournal.com > CongressDaily

    • Home
    • The Magazine
    • The Hotline
    • CongressDaily
    • The Almanac
  • Sunday, May 19, 2013
  • About Us
  • Events
  • News
  • Earlybird
  • Energy
  • Health Care
  • Defense & Diplomacy
  • Technology
  • Economy
  • Congr. Connection Poll
  • Committees
  • Markup Reports
  • The Promise Audit
  • Insider Interviews
  • Blogs
  • Hotline On Call
  • Expert Blogs
  • Tech Daily Dose
  • Multimedia
  • Play of the Day
  • Hotline TV
  • Audio & Video
  • Columns
  • Ronald Brownstein
  • Eliza Newlin Carney
  • Charlie Cook (Tues.)
  • Charlie Cook (Fri.)
  • Josh Kraushaar
  • Jonathan Rauch
  • Bruce Stokes
  • William Schneider
  • Reid Wilson
  • Subscriber Resources
  • The Almanac
  • Daybook
  • Ad Spotlight
  • Affiliate Sites
  • The Atlantic
  • The Cook Political Report
  • Global Security Newswire
  • Government Executive
  • Washington Week
  • WIA
CongressDaily

Search Sponsor:

About CongressDaily
Subscriptions | Contact Us
  • Latest AM
  • Latest 11:30 Extra
  • Latest PM Update
  • Columns
    • 1600
    • Balance of Payments
    • China Watch
    • Forward Observer
    • Health Matters
    • Hotline House Race Extra
    • Looking In
    • Off to the Races
    • Outside Influences
    • People
    • Power Play
    • Wired in Washington
  • Issue Pages
    • Issue Pages
    • 111th Congress
    • Budget/Appropriations
    • Climate Change/Energy
    • Cloakroom
    • Employee Free Choice Act
    • Financial Regulation
    • Health Care
    • Politics
  • Print
    • Print
    • Entire Edition
  • Email
  • Reprints
  • Tools Sponsor:
SENATE

Democrats Line Up To Take More Shots At Filibuster Rules

Thursday, Sept. 23, 2010


The Senate Rules Committee Wednesday held the latest in a series on the future of the filibuster, a day after a GOP filibuster stalled a defense authorization bill and a day before Republican filibuster could block a campaign finance disclosure bill.

The Senate's unique filibuster rules have gained attention lately due to an increase in failed cloture votes and Democrats' efforts to highlight what they call historic GOP obstruction.

Wednesday's Senate Rules Committee meeting was the fifth of six hearings it has held on the subject this year.

Democrats used the hearing to present proposals to reform Senate rules. While seen as unlikely to succeed, they have said the plan has the benefit on keeping a focus on the prevalence of procedural obstructions.

Democrats called the current rules a "broken" and "dysfunctional" system that allows the minority to use the filibuster to force a supermajority vote of 60 senators on legislation.

"The current abuse of the filibuster is like nothing I've seen before," said Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, who presented the panel with a plan to change the filibuster rule. "As scholars have testified, the minority, including Democrats when they were in the minority, has abused the filibuster in recent years at a level without precedent in the history of this body."

Harkin has proposed a plan that would revise the number of votes needed for cloture. He has pushed the measure for 15 years, he said.

Under the first vote for cloture would still need 60 votes. If that fails, three more votes could occur over about eight days. On the last, a majority of 51 votes could invoke cloture and end debate.

Sen. Tom Udall, D-N.M., presented a proposal that would force the Senate to vote to adopt its rules at the beginning of each Congress, which could make it easier for senators to change the rules.

Committee Republicans defended current rules and described their use of procedural prerogatives as necessary to block bad legislation.

Majority Leader Reid has sidelined the GOP through procedural moves that limited their ability to propose amendments, a sore issue on the heels of the defense bill filibuster, Republicans argued.

Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., said in the face of the Democrats' agenda he is proud to call himself an "obstructionist."

"The rules aren't broken," he said. "The attitude of the majority is the problem."

Harkin argued that the traditional power of one senator to slow or stop legislation must be limited.

"For the good of the country, we have to give up a little of that power," he said.

Harkin acknowledged some Republican concerns were valid and asked the expert witnesses how his proposal could include protections for the minority party.

Rules Chairman Charles Schumer said both parties have failed. He promised another hearing to discuss the majority leader's procedural moves.

%C2%AD

by Josh Smith, with Dan Friedman contributing

  • Next: Geithner Promises Vigilance Against Lax Global Enforcement
  • Previous: Obama's Choice To Lead OMB Faces Hurdle: Sen. Sanders  

CongressDaily Email Alerts

CongressDaily Mobile Alerts

Advertisement

9/23/2010 AM Contents

REPUBLICANS

  • Surging Toward November, GOP Promises To Start Over

POLITICAL PROFILE

  • Without Gregg, Granite State Looking At Extreme Makeover

TAXES

  • Senate Democrats Want One Last Try At Outsourcing Bill

TELECOMMUNICATIONS

  • Fate Of Broadband Regulatory Debate Hinges On Elections

TRADE

  • House Democrats To Take Up China Currency Legislation

DEFENSE

  • Injuries Climb With More Army Recruits Unfit For Duty

ENERGY

  • Some In GOP Saw Vindictiveness In Plans For Murkowski
  • Experts Say Carbon Pricing, RES Would Help U.S. Compete

HEALTH

  • State Commissioners Seek Phase-In Of Medical Cost Rule

SENATE

  • Obama's Choice To Lead OMB Faces Hurdle: Sen. Sanders
  • Democrats Line Up To Take More Shots At Filibuster Rules

FINANCE

  • Geithner Promises Vigilance Against Lax Global Enforcement

HEALTH

  • Offset Debate Clouds House Vote On Child Nutrition Bill

FINANCE

  • Frustrations With Flood Insurance Bubble Up Before Panel

PEOPLE

  • Taking Flight

BALANCE OF PAYMENTS

  • Different Definitions Of Normal

HILL BRIEFS

  • Coburn Gags Again On Food Safety Bill
  • DISCLOSE Act Filibuster Is Expected To Succeed
  • Dodaro To Be Tapped As Comptroller General
  • Group Requests Investigation Of Vitter Comments On Aide
  • President Has No Clue About Top Aide's Plans
  • New Push Expected Today For Public Safety Spectrum

Recent News

CongressDaily AM
  • Friday, Oct. 1, 2010
  • Thursday, Sept. 30, 2010
  • Wednesday, Sept. 29, 2010
  • Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010
  • Monday, Sept. 27, 2010
CongressDaily PM Update
  • Friday, Oct. 22, 2010
  • Thursday, Oct. 21, 2010
  • Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2010
  • Tuesday, Oct. 19, 2010
  • Monday, Oct. 18, 2010

Highlights

NationalJournal.com

  • Senate Race Rankings

The Hotline

  • A Well-Built Castle

National Journal Magazine

  • Disenchanted With Obama For Different Reasons
Staff Bios Contact Employment Reprints & Back Issues Privacy Policy Advertising Terms of Service
Copyright 2013 by National Journal Group Inc. The Watergate 600 New Hampshire Ave., NW Washington, DC 20037
202-739-8400 · fax 202-833-8069 NationalJournal.com is an Atlantic Media publication.